"Scholastic" as a Category of Philosophy's Historiography
Abstract
The paper deals with some definitions of scholasticism which can be found in works from the philosophical historiography of our century. Firstly, definitions put forward by Maurice De Wulf (1857-1947) and Martin Grabmann (1875-1949) are discussed. The first of these historians identifies “scholasticism” with one particular philosophy (i.e. an articulated series of doctrines) which, he claims, have existed in the Middle Ages and somehow anticipate of scholasticism with the educational background of medieval scholars; Grabmann, on the other hand, ends by considering scholasticism simply as a theology, if not “the” (only possible) form of theology, and his definition is of no use in the field of the history of philosophy. In the second part, the definitions put forward more recently by Lambert M. De Rijk and George Wieland are considered. These definitions start from the relationship between “auctoritas” and “ratio” and focus on giving a concrete content both to the idea of “authority” (i.e. a set of authoritative texts, different for each faculty) and to “reason”, which must be understood as the particular set of tools of dialectic, as they developed throughout the Middle Ages. Wieland adds to this a series of characteristics of scholasticism, such as the commitment to a topic as a scientific topic, the fact that each discipline is penetrated by philosophy, and the separation between “school” and “life”. The simultaneous appearance of all these characteristics in the 12th century marks the beginning of scholasticism, and can also explain its “dissolution” at the end of the Middle Ages.Downloads
References
De Rijk, L. M. (1981). Middeleeuwse wijsbegeerte. Assen: Van Gorchum (tr. Francesa, 1985, La Philosophie au Moyen Âge. Leiden: Brill).
De Wulf, M. (1903). La décadence de la Scolastique à la fin du Moyen-Âge. Revue néoscolastique de philosophie, 10, 359-371.
De Wulf, M. (1904). Introduction à la Philosophie Néo-Scolastique. Louvain/Paris: Institut supérieur de Philosophie - Félix Alcan.
De Wulf, M. (1924). Histoire de la philosophie médiévale, 5ta ed., T. I, Des origines jusqu’à Thomas d’Aquin. Louvain: Institut supérieur de philosophie.
De Wulf, M. (1925). Histoire de la philosophie médiévale, 5ta ed., T. II, De Thomas d’Aquin jusqu’à la fin du Moyen-Âge. Paris/Louvain: Alcan-Institut supérieur de philosophie.
De Wulf, M. (1934-1936). Histoire de la philosophie médiévale, 6ta ed. Louvain/Paris: Nauwelaerts (trad. Italiana di V. Miano, 1944, Firenze: Libreria Editrice Fiorentina).
Del Punta, F. & Luna, C. (1992-1993). La teologia scolastica. In Cavallo, G., Leonardi, C. & Menestò, E. (dir.). Lo spazio letterario del Medioevo, 1. Il Medioevo Latino, vol. 1 (in 2 tomi), La produzione del testo, t. II. Roma: Ed. Salerno, 323-353.
Farge, J. K. (1980). Biographical Register of Paris Doctors of Theology, 1500-1536 (Subsidia Mediaevalia, 10). Toronto: Pontifical Institute of Medieval Studies.
Flasch, K. (1987). Einführung in die Philosophie des Mittelalters. Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft.
Flasch, K. (1991). La concezione storiografica della filosofia in Baeumker e Grabmann. In Imbach, R. & Maier, A. (eds.). Gli studi di filosofia medievale fra Otto e Novecento, Contributo a un bilancio storiografico. Roma: Ed. di Storia e Letteratura, 51-73.
Giacon, C. SJ (1981). Per una prima genesi delle XXIV tesi del tomismo specifico. Doctor Communis, 34, 175-193.
Giacon, C. SJ (1982). Postille sulle tesi del tomismo specifico. Doctor Communis, 35, 349-356.
Giacon, C. SJ (1982). Il ‘Cursus Forojuliensis’ e le XXIV tesi del tomismo specifico. In L’Enciclica Aeterni Patris, Atti dell’VIII Congresso Tomistico Internazionale, vol. III. Città del Vaticano: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 157-194.
Glorieux, P. (1968). L’enseignement au Moyen Âge, Techniques et méthodes en usage à la faculté de Théologie de Paris au XIIIe siècle. Archive Histoire Doctrinale Littéraire du Moyen Âge, 65-186.
Grabmann, M. (1909). Geschichte der scholastischen Methode, Bd. I. Freiburg in Br.: Herder.
Grabmann, M. (1911). Geschichte der scholastischen Methode, Bd. II. Freiburg in Br.: Herder (tr. Italiana, 1980, Firenze: La Nuova Italia).
Koch, J. (1961). Scholastik. Religion in Geschichte und Gegenwart, 5, 1494-1498.
LeGoff, J. (1957). Les intellectuels au Moyen Âge. Paris: Éditions du Seuil.
Makdisi, G. (1993). The Model of Islamic Scholastic Culture and its Later Parallel in the Christian West. In Weijers, O. (ed.). Vocabulario des college’s universitaires. Turnhout: Brepols, 158-174.
Mattiussi, G. (1917). Le XXIV tesi della filosofia di S. Tommaso d’Aquino. Roma: Università Gregoriana (trad. italiana di P. B. Grenet, 1965, Le 24 tesi tomiste, Roma, Edizione Paoline).
Micheli, G. (1981). La ‘Historia philosophica’ nella scolastica tedesca. In Bottin, F. et al. (eds.). Storia delle storie generali della Filosofia, vol. I: Dalle origini rinascimentali alla ‘Historia philosophica’. Brescia: La Scuola, 427-437.
Ott, L. (1956). Bibliographie. In Mittelalterliches Geistesleben, Bd. III. München: Hueber, 10-35.
Quiles, I. (1960). Contribución a la historiografía de la escolástica medieval de los siglos XVII y XVIII. En Wenin, Ch. (ed.). L’homme et son destino d’après les penseurs du Moyen Âge, Actes du premier congrès international de philosophie médiévale, Louvain-Bruxelles 28 août-4 septembre 1958. Louvain/Paris: B. Nauwelaerts, 729-741.
Quinto, R. (1991). ‘Scholastica’, Contributo alla storia di un concetto. I. Sino al secolo XIII. Medioevo. Revista di storia della filosofía medievale, 17, 1-82.
Quinto, R. (1993). ‘Scholastica. Contributo alla storia di un concetto. II. Secoli XIII-XVI. Medioevo. Rivista di storia della filosofía medievale, 19, 67-165.
Quinto, R. (1996). ‘Scholastica. Contributo alla storia di un concetto. III. Da Lutero al XVIII secolo. Medioevo, Rivista di storia della filosofía medievale, 22, 335-451.
Quinto, R. (1996). Trivium e teologia, L’organizzazione scolastica nella seconda metà del secolo dodicesimo e i maestri della sacra pagina. In D’Onofrio, G. (ed.). Storia della Teologia nel Medioevo, II. Casale Monferrato: Piemme, 435-468.
Rosemann, P. W. (1994). Histoire et actualité de la méthode scolastique selon M. Grabmann. In Follon, J. & McEvoy, J. (eds.). Actualité de la pensée médiévale (Philosophes médiévaux, 31). Louvain la Neuve/Louvain/Paris: Institut supérieur de Philosophie/Peeters, 95-118.
Rosemann, P. W. (2000). Martin Grabmann. In Damico, H. (ed.). Medieval Scholarship, Biographical Studies on the Formation of a Discipline, vol. 3: Philosophy and the Arts. New York/London: Routledge, 55-74.
Steel, C. (1994). La philosophie médiévale comme expression de son époque. In Follon, J. & McEvoy, J. (eds.). Actualité de la pensée médiévale (Philosophes médiévaux, 31). Louvain la Neuve/Louvain/Paris: Institut supérieur de Philosophie/Peeters, 79-93.
Von Döllinger, J. (Hrsg.) (1882). Quellen zur Papstgeschichte des 14. bis 17. Jahrhunderts, insbesondere der Reformation und des Konzils von Trient, Bd. III: Beiträge zur politischen, kirchlichen und Kultur-Geschichte der sechsletzten Jahrhunderte, Bd. III. Wien: Manz [Re-edited 1967, Frankfurt: Minerva]
Wieland, G. (1981). Ethica - scientia practica, Die Anfänge der philosophischen Ethik im 13. Jahrhundert. Münster: Aschendorff.
1. The authors who publish in this magazine accept the following conditions:
-
They retain the copyright and grant to the magazine the right of the first publication, with the work registered under the Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License that allows third parties to use what is published as long as they mention the authorship of the work and the first publication in this magazine.
-
They can make other independent and additional contractual agreements for the non-exclusive distribution of the version of the article published in this magazine (eg. include it in an institutional repository or publish it in a book) provided that they clearly indicate that the work was first published in this journal.
-
They are allowed and recommended to publish their work on the Internet (for example on institutional or personal pages).
2. AutoArchive Conditions. Authors are allowed and encouraged to distribute post-print electronic versions of their manuscripts because it promotes their circulation, a possible increase of quotation and a major reach among the Academic community. Color RoMEO: blue.
